Auntie Sally again… with a preferment!

I’m making Auntie Sally’s challah dough for Yom Tov (third and final batch of dough!) because I think it will make a couple of nice challahs along with some excellent cinnamon buns.  I have yet to make really EXCELLENT pareve cinnamon buns, so here’s hoping.

I’m modifying my formula from last time, splitting it up to include a bit of a preferment.  Why the heck not???  Why a preferment and not an autolyse, like this winning recipe from Challah Crumbs (which I very nearly selected)?  I dunno.  I have some time… why not let the stuff sit in a bowl as long as possible?

So here’s the same recipe, divided, with 25% of the flour in the preferment.  I estimated 140g for a cup last time, so I’m keeping that the same.


  • 2 cups bread flour = 280g
  • 1 cup of sugar = 200g
  • 4 tsp yeast = 24g Going to try to reduce this to 14g
  • 2.5 cups of warm water = 600g (whoah, this is going to be SLOPPY…)

Postscript:  indeed, it was very sloppy.  Here it is after 2.5 hours or so fermenting in a large covered bowl.

breads 001

The final dough:

  • 6 cups 8 cups of flour = 840g 1120g, plus some to sprinkle
  • 1 cup of canola oil = 210g
  • 1 tsp salt = 4.8g
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 egg white No, this is silly!  I’m skipping the one egg white.
  • Shouldn’t need additional water… but it might.

Let’s see how this goes!

Postscript:  indeed, it didn’t need additional water.  It needed additional FLOUR.  Much of it.

breads 002

Two cups of additional flour, all-told, hence the adjusted totals above.  Plus some sprinkled on the table so the stuff wouldn’t absorb my hands as I kneaded.

But in the end, it did make a beautiful dough:

breads 004

And now it’s in the bucket in the fridge to sit & rise overnight.


Know what else you're gonna love?

Baking in Israel? Beware of FAKE condensed milk

Baking maven Paula Shoyer declares war on kichel. This killer recipe proves her wrong.

Simply Gorgeous Vegan & Pareve Florentine Cookies

More delicious kosher morsels!