Quest for the Perfect Challah: Suggestions…?

image Since this blog appears to have a few readers now., and by “a few” I mean the traditional usage of “THREE,” I’m just curious…

This week’s non-challah Shabbos is perhaps indicative of my general “challah ennui” (is it a googlewhack? no: 4340 hits), and I want a new recipe – a new challenge, maybe.

What’s your favourite challah? Does anyone want to bail us out by sending a challah recipe you absolutely LOVE?

What I like, in general: challah must be sweet. It must not have too much whole wheat, but some, or some spelt, is just fine. I do not love EGGS in challah, but most of our challahs lately have been made with eggs.

I am particularly looking for “next-day” challahs… ie, a loaf you are not afraid to bite into, perhaps slightly warmed on the blech but nevertheless officially “day-old” bread.

We are torn on the “density “ issue. Elisheva adores a thick, heavy loaf. I tend to prefer a bit on the fluffier side. I guess that means we’re open-minded.

If you’ve read this blog a bit, you know I’ve become picky about measurements and prefer to measure the REAL way – by weight. Anything else is guesswork. I will measure yeast, salt etc in tablespoons, and water/oil/honey in cups (though weights are fine for these, too), but dry like flour and sugar should be scaled. Metric or otherwise – my scale can handle anything!

So, nu? Hit me with your best challah recipe! I will try it and report back. If yours is a winner with the family, well… like I tell my kids, you’ll come away with the great satisfaction of a job well done.

p.s. Cake recipes welcome also. Preferably pareve. Preferably TONIGHT, in time to make for Shabbos tomorrow. :-)))


  1. Hi there,
    I seem to share your quest for the perfect challot. If you check out my blog, there are a number of challah recipes that meet that criteria. Check out

  2. Lol I have yet to even attempt the challah bread. It's on my list but I have a few cakes to make first. I finally got a flakey puffy pie pastry down though! And I love your blog. I come here before I go to or betty crocker to get a bread recipe.

  3. Just found your blog and I love it. If you're looking for the perfect challah, I may have the answer for you. This is my go-to challah, I've been baking it practically every week for the past 6 or 7 years.

    I have yet to blog about it, but it's coming soon...

  4. Thanks for dropping by! I will have to try it (big fan of recipezaar - anything 11 anonymous Internet users bake & love must be at least half-decent). To be honest, though, we LOVED Chavi's, so that's in line for this week.

    Hey, what am I even doing, thinking about bread on a fast day? :-o


Post a Comment

Okay, guys... I'm turning moderation OFF on all my blogs. I will be patrolling for spam, so play nice!

Know what else you're gonna love?

Baking in Israel? Beware of FAKE condensed milk

Easy, tender, and affordable roast in Israel… yes, it IS possible!

Super-Easy Thick, Spreadable, Bakeable DIY Cream Cheese in Israel

More delicious kosher morsels!