The “I Give Up on Sourdough” Hybrid Sourdough Challah

doughs 2009-09-11 005 Yup!  I have officially given up on trying to produce a delicious sourdough challah.  All attempts so far have either been completely leaden and barely-risen or just plain WEIRD (the “sweet-and-sourdough” challah I made with honey; it was really WAY too tangy, and the sweetness just put it over the top).

So this week I’m making a “hybrid.”  Yup, it’s not just for cars anymore… this hybrid challah will hopefully offer the best of the sourdough and commercial-yeast worlds.

First, I made a sponge, from this recipe, and left it overnight.  It easily tripled or quadrupled its size (see above).

Then, I took about four cups of flour and mixed my regular challah things in:  salt, sugar.  I used less sugar than usual – I don’t want a repeat of the sweet-and-sour effect.  And 1 tbsp of Fleishman’s Instant Yeast.  Gasp. 

But I have just NOT gotten the leavening power yet out of wild yeast that would make me comfortable serving the breads to my family as a Shabbos treat.  If it’s too dense, it thuds on the challah board in a most unappealing way.

doughs 2009-09-11 006Here’s the finished dough after kneading.  I did add a bit of water, between 1/2 and 3/4 cup?  Just enough to make it kneadable; there wasn’t enough sponge to moisten this much flour.


So… here’s the dough, resting in a bag.  Shameful commercial yeast at its side.

  doughs 2009-09-11 007 

It rose beautifully to almost fill the bag!  Forgot to take a picture.

Shaped into loaves:

doughs 2009-09-11 024

They also rose beautifully – NICE, for a change!  And here they are, fully baked:

Friday challah 2009-09-11 001

I didn’t brush the tops or sprinkle them with anything or spray them with water – just baked them as-is.  That’s because taste is the most important thing.  There’s no point fancying them up if they’re going to taste awful.

These two came out of the oven SO light and delicious-smelling.  Well, I have a terrible cold, so I can’t really smell anything, but they look like they smell delicious, and I can kind of catch a whiff through my plugged-up nose.

As with all Shabbos challah, there’s an element of suspense:  I have to wait until after sunset to taste it, and until tomorrow night to report back on whether or not it was actually as yummy as it looked!


Know what else you're gonna love?

Baking in Israel? Beware of FAKE condensed milk

Super-Easy Thick, Spreadable, Bakeable DIY Cream Cheese in Israel

Easy, tender, and affordable roast in Israel… yes, it IS possible!

More delicious kosher morsels!